Waterford tenant who claimed €15,000 of possessions were dumped after eviction loses case

 An RTB tribunal rejected an application taken by the tenantplaceholder image
An RTB tribunal rejected an application taken by the tenant | Stock Image

The Residential Tenancies Board (RTB) dismissed the case concerning an apartment in Dungarvan, County Waterford

A tenant who claimed €15,000 worth of personal belongings were disposed of following her eviction from a property in Waterford has had her case dismissed by the Residential Tenancies Board (RTB).

A tribunal rejected an application taken by Jennifer McCarthy against Focus Housing Association CLG concerning an apartment at Convent Lodge, Mitchel Street, Dungarvan, ruling that the housing body had not breached its obligations when it cleared the property a month after it was repossessed.

The tenancy had commenced on September 6, 2015 and ended on June 3, 2025 when the tenant was removed by the Sheriff.

The tribunal heard that rent arrears had long been an issue, leading to a 2023 adjudicator determination which found arrears of €9,593.14 and validated a notice of termination served in June 2022.

Focus Housing Association subsequently obtained an order in its favour from the Circuit Court in February 2024, ordering the Sheriff to remove the occupants. Notification was hand-delivered to Ms McCarthy, and the Sheriff executed the repossession in June 2025.

Housing Manager Gráinne Murphy told the tribunal that €27,728.86 had been expended on the dwelling due to breaches of standard and maintenance obligations alongside rent arrears.

This total comprised €21,469.58 in rent arrears up to June 2025, €1,940 for electrical damage, €2,213.40 for cleaning and debris removal, and €2,100 for repainting, excluding work carried out by the organisation’s ground maintenance crew.

Ms Murphy stated that Focus Housing Association had arranged for a security company to clear the property of furniture, appliances, and flooring to prepare it for reletting under its responsibilities to the local authority.

A report from the security company noted that every room had to be cleared of domestic waste and furniture, all flooring removed and disposed of, internal walls deep-cleaned and repainted, and live wiring running to a back garden shed dismantled for safety reasons after its roof collapsed.

On-site caretaker John Nolan testified that he was present during the eviction and observed the apartment in a “terrible state”, describing it as full of dog faeces, filthy, covered in mould, and that the only item Ms McCarthy took with her was her dog.

He stated that the Sheriff had told her to leave and take what she wanted, adding that the back shed was filled with rubbish and that the smell was “unbelievable”.

In her submission, Ms McCarthy stated that she had been given only half an hour to remove her possessions when the Sheriff arrived. She alleged that she had phoned the landlord numerous times to arrange collection but the calls were never answered.

When questioned about the condition of the home, Ms McCarthy said, “I know how I was living,” adding that there was no point saying anything because nobody wanted to hear.

She told the tribunal that she knew the Sheriff was coming but did not know the date, and explained that she had not removed her belongings earlier because she had nowhere to go and no storage.

She claimed that €15,000 worth of possessions had been left in the apartment and that she now had nothing.

The tribunal found that text messages showed a support worker had offered Ms McCarthy opportunities to collect her belongings on three occasions but she had failed to keep any appointments.

The tribunal determined that, while a landlord must act reasonably regarding possessions after an eviction, it is not responsible for storing or maintaining personal items once a tenancy has officially concluded.

It found that the one-month period afforded had been reasonable, and Focus Housing Association was entitled to clear the property to prepare it for re-use.

Related topics:
Register
Follow us
© 2026 Formpress Publishing LTD. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice